Note for reference: Sometimes Aunt Agatha will give money instead of an item. It sucks, but it happens. Unfortunately, she can only show up once per episode so if you get the item you didn’t want (whether it be money or one of the times she has multiple options), you’ll have to redo the episode.
And of course, you may need to go in and out of areas for her to show up. She rarely is there on your first check x__x I’ve spent over 200AP once trying to find her and I was in the right place, it’s just partially luck based.
- Episode 1: Pearl Necklace – During when you have to get everything to finalize your registration, she’s in the Hallway or Student Council Room (I want to say everyone gets this since it introduces you to her but??)
- Episode 2: Rainbow Ball Bracelet – When trying to get the Absentee note signed by Castiel, she can be found in the garden. You can also find her there after your club duties as well.
- Episode 3: Belly Button Ring – When the toy, collar, and leash fail and you need to get the biscuits from Castiel/find him for the idea, you can find Agatha in the gym.
- Episode 4: Sunglasses – In the Garden after getting the first two items from the stairs.
- Episode 5: Sherlock Cape – While waiting for the Principal to leave so you can go to the teacher’s lounge, she’ll be in the staircase. You can also find her there while searching for the key. If you are having trouble, what I found to finally properly give me the item was to NOT touch the stairs at all until after I checked the Teacher’s Room and got the pipe (even if I already had it–just clicking it again).
- Episode 6: Halo or Devil Horns – When you need to buy paper and a pen for Lysander to write a poem, you can find her in Classroom A. You can also find her in Classroom A after asking Rosa where she lost her ring. Depending on if you help Rosa and Leigh or try to break them up determines what item you get at the end of the episode if you found her. You get the Halo if you helped them and the Devil Horns if you get the Leigh illustration.
- Episode 7: Birdie, Bunny, or Panda Slippers – After getting the snacks from school–you can find her in Melody’s house in the hallway (go between the bathroom and hall as going into the bedroom will continue everything). It’s random which you get. You need to play three times to get them all. You can supposedly find her from the first time you get there as well before you find out about the missing snacks.
- Episode 8: Grilled Toast, Jam Toast, or Chocolate Toast – She can be found in Classroom A after talking to Kim and the boys about where to study. It’s random which toast you get.
- Episode 9: Swan Float – This one sucks to get. It can be found at the Northern Beach either when you need to find the seller or after meeting Dake (though, I believe I’ve gotten it during other objectives too). Since just walking along the beach also progresses the story, you could easily finish the episode without getting it. This took me several replays to finally get lucky and get it.
- Episode 10: Gold Graduation Cap, Graduation Cap, or Text Book – She can be found in the Staircase or Room A before you run into Alexy in the Courtyard, which hat you get depends on your results in Episode 8 (so you’d have to do a story replay to get the others -_-). Gold Graduation Cap is what you get if you aced your tests, the normal Graduation Cap if you did okay, and the book if you failed.
- Episode 11: Backpack – When you need to find your teammate for the race, you can find her in the Student Council Room.
- Episode 12: Smart Phone – You can find her in the locker room after you get caught by Nathaniel or before you buy Amber a phone.
- Episode 13: Stereo – She’s in the locker room again. You can find her while collecting money or before you talk to Nina.
- Episode 14: Headphones – In the locker room once more either before or after talking to Nina (As in both–not as in I’m not sure which).
- Episode 15: Vintage Dress or Vintage Camera – Still in the locker room… Before/After buying Deborah’s album. Random which you get. Need to play again for the other.
- Episode 16: Chocolate Bar Necklace – She’s still haunting the locker room. She’ll be there either while Iris, Violette, and Alexy are avoiding you, when you’re looking for comfort, and before you talk to Rosa.
- Episode 17: Baseball Bat – Classroom B while either looking for Lysander or Castiel.
- Episode 18: Bunny Ears – When you need to find Peggy or After rescuing the rabbits, you can find her in the Gym, Garden, or Student Council Room.
- Episode 19: Blue Dot Clutch with Pink Flower – She’s in the Sunglasses store. You can find her after talking to Lucy for the first time.
- Episode 20: Happy Mask or Sad Mask – Either when you’re looking for everyone’s reactions to the play at the start, looking for Violette and Kim or when trying to find a quiet room to practice. You get asked a question and if you pick A. Macbeth, you get the sad mask. If you pick B. Hamlet, you get the happy one. Have to play twice for both.
- Episode 21: Alice Flamingo Club, Riding Hood Basket, or Beauty Thorn Rose – During Go back to the Gym or when waiting/looking for your parents, you can find her in the Garden. You can also find her after a guy helps you with the fabric for Rosa or when talking to the others about the play. You get whichever coincides with the play you picked so you need to replay 3 times and also do the AP play change for all 3.
- Episode 22: Adventurer’s Hat – During the Treasure Hunt when looking for the first three items, you can find her in Classroom A.
- Episode 23: Panda Kigurumi – When trying to find Amber, you can find her in the Science Room. You can also find it when looking for someone to talk to about Nathaniel.
- Episode 24: Robotic Dog or Robotic Cat – During your date at the pet shop. Before you go to the cat and dog aisle page, keep going between the Register and Accessories and Rodent Aisle until she shows up. Which you get is random so you have to play twice for both.
- Episode 25: Green Flask – While looking for where to buy your outfit for Science Class or before you go to the gym to purchase it, you can find her in the basement. You can also find her when spying.
- Episode 26: Straw Hat – While going with Rosa to buy Picnic Supplies, you can find her at the Shops before you go home. You can also find her there after meeting with the others at the Cafe and before talking to Nina.
- Episode 27: Henna Tattoo – In the Library. When looking for Nathaniel when you’re trying to find him with Kim or after you overhear Amber’s plan to do something to Priya.
- Episode 28: Cupid’s Bow and Arrow – When you need to go back to school after the date, she can be found in the Park or Park Entrance.
- Episode 29: Drawing Folder – When gathering everyone for Classroom B, you can find her Upstairs (in front of the science room/upstairs hall).
- Episode 30: Bunny Sweater – When you need to follow Lysander upstairs, she appears in Classroom B and Classroom A.
- Episode 31: Stethoscope – When looking for Lysander’s doctor to tell him about Nina. You can find her in the first Hospital Room and the 3rd floor hallway.
- Episode 32: Hairnet Cap – When you need to ask your parents if Rosalya can sleepover, you can find her at the park entrance.
- Episode 33: Party Props – Either when you bring the dishes to the living room or when isolating yourself to write down a dare. You can find her in the Garden or Thomas’ Room.
- Episode 34: Spaghetti Bowl – When you leave the cafeteria after the incident or while looking for Iris’ phone, you can find her in the basement.
- Episode 35: Polaroid – During Go back to the high school when you hope to find Iris’ Blackmailer in the Gardens, you can find Aunt Agatha at the Park Entrance at night, Cafe at night, or Shops at night.
- Episode 36: Unicorn Mask – You find Agatha at the Shops during the very first objective.
- Episode 37: Cloud Purse – She can be found in the Park at night before meeting the Twins (+ boyfriend if not Armin or Kentin) at the bus after getting ready in your room.
- Episode 38: Rainbow Hair/Wigs – When you first wake up after studying in the library and find yourself locked in the school (during the dream sequence), she appears in the cafeteria after you’ve checked the courtyard. Which wig you get is random.
- Episode 39: Glass Shoes/Slippers – After getting ready for prom with your friends, you can find her in the park at night.
- Episode 40: Graduation Gown, Graduation Medal, and Golden Laurels – After going to your locker with Rosalya when you decide to go look for your friends, you can find her in the Science Room. Which item you get is random.